Posts

Responding to: (This article belongs to the Special Issue Sufism and Contemporary Islamic Studies)

  https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/16/2/234 To truly reclaim the narrative, you must first understand how and why they (Western or non-Muslim institutions) are interpreting Islamic history the way they do — then, through reflection and discernment, extract what aligns with truth , filter what’s distorted , and reintegrate what has been lost from our own side. 🔍 What They Are Saying (and Why) Here’s a simplified breakdown of what mainstream academic narratives usually say about the “Islamic Golden Age” (roughly 8th–14th century) — and the reasoning or motivation behind them: 💡 1. Framing it as a Rational/Scientific Renaissance What they say: The Islamic Golden Age was a period where Muslim societies made major contributions to science, medicine, philosophy, and the arts — not because of religion , but because they were “open to Greek knowledge” and had strong state-sponsored scholarship under the Abbasids. Why they frame it this way: This supports the Enlightenment-styl...

Evidence shows that much Shia research was focussed on preserving hadiths etc. The Question: Why have we not kept up original scientific practices - this being true?

Many Sincere Seekers have also posed this same Question: It’s true that much of Shia Islamic scholarship, especially after the major occultation, focused on preserving hadiths, jurisprudence (fiqh), and theology (kalam). This was a critical survival strategy. After the fall of the Imam’s visible leadership, the community was vulnerable — politically, socially, and spiritually. So the scholars focused on safeguarding what was left: texts, narrations, and law. But here’s where things shifted: 🕰 Why Practices Were Lost or Weakened Loss of Direct Imamate Guidance During the era of the Imams, especially with Imam Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq, practice and knowledge were deeply interwoven. The Imams didn’t just teach what to do, but how and why — and more importantly, when it was safe to do it. After the occultation, scholars had to rely on texts without access to the full inner meanings or timing of application. In that vacuum, caution prevailed. Anything mystical, esoteric, or deeply en...

How much Shia Islamic research has been done on this?

Very little sys tematic Shia Islamic research   has been done on the full 780-year "Golden Era" as a continuous civilizational arc. Most of the historical narrative is dominated by Sunni perspectives , particularly because: The ruling dynasties (Umayyads, Abbasids, etc.) were Sunni. Shia scholarship often focused more on preserving hadith, theology, and Imamate doctrine during times of political marginalization. Much of the historical and scientific documentation was written outside of Shia scholarly circles , even though many scientific and spiritual figures were Shia or Shia-leaning. However, important segments of this history have been addressed by Shia scholars and thinkers—especially through the lens of Imamate, oppression, occultation, and revival. 🔹 What Shia Scholarship Has Focused On 1. The Lives and Teachings of the 12 Imams Deep study of their historical role in shaping Islamic ethics, knowledge, and resistance to tyranny. Many books ana...

Islamic Golden Age - Resources

To get the most accurate and comprehensive information about the 780 years of the Golden Era (presumably referring to the Islamic Golden Age), the best approach is multi-layered research from a combination of classical sources, academic scholarship, and thematic focus . Here's a detailed roadmap for you: 🧭 STEP 1: Define the Framework Before diving in, clarify: Are you referring to 780 lunar years (approx. 750 solar years)? Do you mean from the time of the Prophet (s) to the fall of Baghdad (1258 CE)? Or from a certain dynastic period (e.g. Umayyad, Abbasid)? 📚 STEP 2: Core Primary & Classical Islamic Sources These won’t directly frame it as a “golden era,” but offer the firsthand spiritual and intellectual foundation : Tārīkh al-Ṭabarī (History of al-Tabari) – earliest and most detailed Islamic historical chronicle. Ibn Khaldūn's Muqaddimah – analysis of civilizations and their rise and fall, very useful for understanding the cultural shifts...